Submit an external teacher evaluation in Xello
userEducator Xello productXello 6-12 Time4 minutes

Students applying to colleges through Common App can request teacher evaluations from educators outside their current school district. When a student requests a recommendation for a Common App institution, you will receive an email invitation to submit your evaluation through a secure external portal.

The teacher evaluation is sent to all the Common App colleges the student has assigned to you. This means you only need to fill it out once. Make sure your letter is specific to the student's accomplishments and not to the institution they're applying to.

In this article

Access and verification

Once a student submits an evaluation request, you'll receive an email invitation with a link to Xello to begin. You'll enter your email address to receive a temporary access code, sign a waiver, and log in to your Xello external teacher portal.

To access and verify an external teacher Xello account: 

  1. Open the email invitation from Xello and click View request.
    • The email will include the name of the student, where they're applying, the deadline, and a link to view the request.
  2. Enter your email address to be sent a sign-in code.
    • The code will expire in 10 minutes after being sent. If you didn't get to it in time, you can request a new code.
  3. Enter the 6-digit code sent to your email and click Continue.
  4. Review the terms, confirm you are at least 18 years old, accept the waiver, and click Accept and continue to access your external teacher portal.

up arrowBack to top

Set up your teacher profile

Before you can submit an evaluation, Common App requires basic contact and professional details for your profile. This information is saved to the high school listed in the student's request and carries over for future requests from that same school.

To complete your teacher profile: 

  1. In the Complete your teacher profiles banner, click Complete profile.
    External referrer requests tab, the cursor is clicking Complete profile
    Click to enlarge
    External referrer requests tab, the cursor is clicking Complete profile
  2. Next to the listed school, click Set up profile.
    External referrer profiles tab, the cursor is clicking Set up profile
    Click to enlarge
    External referrer profiles tab, the cursor is clicking Set up profile
  3. In the teacher profile form, complete all required personal and school details and click Complete.
    The teacher profile form, including personal and school details
    Click to enlarge
    The teacher profile form, including personal and school details
    • If you've received requests from students for more than one high school, you'll need to complete this profile for each high school.

up arrowBack to top

Complete and send the recommendation

After setting up your teacher profile, you can fill out the evaluation form and upload your letter of recommendation.

To complete and send the recommendation for the student:

  1. On the Requests page, in the row of the student request, click Fill out form.
    Requests tab is open. The cursor is clicking Fill out form next to a student request
    Click to enlarge
    Requests tab is open. The cursor is clicking Fill out form next to a student request
  2. Complete the required fields, including subject area taught, and written evaluations.
  3. At the bottom of the form, click Upload PDF to attach your formal letter of recommendation.
    The referrer form filled out and scrolled to the bottom of the page where the cursor is clicking Upload PDF
    Click to enlarge
    The referrer form filled out and scrolled to the bottom of the page where the cursor is clicking Upload PDF
  4. Once you've finished filling out the form, click Complete.
    • Alternatively, you can click Save draft to save your work and complete it later.
  5. A green banner will indicate you've successfully completed the teacher evaluation and you'll be returned to the Requests page.
    • The student request will have a status of Ready to send.
  6. To send the form to Common App, click Send now.
    Requests page for an external referrer. A form has been completed and is ready to send. The cursor is clicking Send now
    Click to enlarge
    Requests page for an external referrer. A form has been completed and is ready to send. The cursor is clicking Send now
    • A green banner will indicate the teacher evaluation was successfully sent.

up arrowBack to top

Video walkthrough

Check out this quick video walkthrough of the steps you'll need to complete to send a recommendation for a student:

up arrowBack to top

Additional resources

  • pdfPDF
    PDFCollege applications for counselors - educator guide New

    Use this guide as a timeline of educator tools, tracking reports, and shareable guides to support students through every stage of the college application process in Xello.

  • pdfPDF
    PDFCommon App guide - educator guide

    Use this guide to learn how students use Common App in Xello, and how you set up a Common App profile, complete student requests, track their progress, and more.

  • youtubeShort video
    Short videoRequesting college documents in Xello - video for students

    Share this video with students to help them track their college application journey with Xello's College Planning section. Learn how they create application trackers for institutions they're applying to and how Xello will automatically pull in deadlines to help manage their application checklists.

  • short videoShort Video
    Short VideoLinking your Common App to Xello - video for students

    A student-facing video covering how students link their Common App account with Xello.

  • pdfPDF
    PDFCommon App and Xello - student guide

    Share this guide with your students to help them link their Xello and Common App accounts, prefill profile data, and request recommendations.

  • pdfPDF
    PDFCommon App teacher recommender - educator guide

    This guide will help recommenders set up a Common App profile, review and action student requests, submit and unsubmit teacher evaluations.

  • pdfPDF
    PDFExternal referrers in Xello - educator guide

    Share this step-by-step walkthrough for mentors, employers, and external recommenders submitting letters or Common App evaluations requested by students in Xello.

  • live webinarWalkthrough
    WalkthroughCommon App integration walkthrough

    This walkthrough covers how students link their Common App account to Xello to request documents, how educators create a Common App profile, and manage and track student requests.

  • pdfPDF
    PDFCommon App annual tasks - admin and counselor guide

    A guide to help admin and counselors with wind-down tasks before the end of the Common App school year and start-up tasks before the next.

  • pdfXello Academy
    Xello AcademyXello + Common App for Counselors

    If you're a counselor at a school that uses Common App, then you'd benefit from this course. You'll understand your role in the process, as well as steps for teacher recommenders and students.

  • live webinarRecorded webinar
    Recorded WebinarXello and Common App 101

    Xello and Common App have partnered to deliver an integrated college application management experience. In this session, learn how you and your students will manage Common App applications through Xello.

  • pdfShort video
    Short videoPaying for college - student-facing video

    Help students learn how to navigate their financial aid options. From applying for FAFSA to learning about scholarships, grants, work-study, and loans.

  • short videoShort Video
    Short VideoRequesting your documents for Common App - video for students

    A student-facing short video that walks through how to request documents for Common App in Xello.

  • pdfShort Video
    Short VideoXello's Common App integration for counselors

    A short video to walk counselors through how to integrate and begin completing tasks for Common App in Xello.

  • pdfShort Video
    Short VideoCommon App teacher recommender through Xello

    A quick overview of how teachers complete teacher evaluations for students applying to Common App colleges.